Interviews
Mom sees old baseball mitt at Goodwill and remembers it from 40 years earlier
What’s amazing is how it somehow followed them across the country and ended up in their neighborhood Goodwill.
Jessica Adler
02.03.23

It’s always a good cause for celebration when we have something of value returned to us. Especially when that value is sentimental or precious in nature.

While most of the time when we lose things they’re sitting right under our noses, sometimes things become genuinely lost and end up in the unlikeliest of places.

Sometimes they end up at Goodwill.

One family lost track of a precious item only to have it turn up in their neighborhood Goodwill, all the way across the country from where they originally lost it.

Pexels - Max Rottersman
Source:
Pexels - Max Rottersman

Julie Anne and Mike Lisi are a couple from Ohio that was spending some vacation time in Tequesta, Florida when something amazing happened.

Julie Anne went thrifting.

The couple would regularly spend time in their vacation home during the summer, doing all of the fun summer things you do in a beach town like Tequesta.

One day, Julie Anne was shopping in the nearby Goodwill when she noticed something strange.

YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8

Then she saw it.

Simply browsing, Julie Anne noticed something familiar hidden among the shelves, an old baseball mitt.

This wasn’t any ordinary baseball glove, however, because it had some familiar handwriting inside.

YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8

Incredibly, the handwriting appeared to belong to Julie Anne’s son, Christopher.

“I just walked in and there sitting on the edge of a shelf on the bottom shelf was this mitt, sitting so that I could see the name, ‘Christopher Lisi’ on it,” Julie Anne Lisi told WPTV.

The mitt was hiding something else.

YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8

Taking the glove off the shelf, Julie Anne took a photo of it and sent it to Christopher, her son.

Holding the glove in her hands, Julie Anne explained that she was totally overcome with emotion.

The coincidence was too much.

Especially after how long ago the glove had been lost, plus that it showed up over a thousand miles away.

YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8

“My knees got wobbly and I got weak and scared,” Julie Anne said.

Mike, her husband, took a look at the glove as well:

“She was in tears, shaking then she showed me the glove and I understood,” Mike told WPTV.

YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8

Only a few moments later, she got a text from Christopher.

He told her to “Buy It.”

For the small price of $1.49, Julie Anne held a priceless childhood heirloom that the family had believed to be gone forever.

The baseball glove had gone missing over 40 years ago in Ohio, right after Christopher had won a championship baseball game back in 1978.

YouTube - WFLA Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA Channel 8

He was only 12 years old.

In that game, he had hit two home runs. At some point during the game, it had been set down, never to be seen again.

“He had won the championship and in the hullaballoo and the handing out of trophies he probably set it down on a bench and somebody walked away with it,” Mike explained.

What makes the find even more incredible is that Julie Anne had never donated anything besides books to Goodwill (in Ohio).

In other words, the journey of how the glove got to the Florida store is a mystery.

YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8
Source:
YouTube - WFLA News Channel 8

All of this led Julie Anne to a single, inspiring conclusion.

“To me, it’s a miracle.”

Learn more about Julie Anne’s sentimental “miracle” find in the video below!

Please SHARE this with your friends and family.

Article Sources:
To learn more read our Editorial Standards.
Advertisement